go with the 58 pilot if you put in a 170 main or larger, you won't regret it...
i just got through making the rear lights run/turn on the 800...
there's a motorcycle repair shop down from my house that i stopped in today to see if he had some "kick out pegs" i could use to make my own foot resting pegs (i don't like crash bars)...we got to talking and i asked him if that was his 1200. he said yes, it is..i replied nice bike, i like it...he said thanks, but it runs like chit...i asked what was wrong...he said and i direct quote which i think is cool
"i can work on any part of the bike i want to but the damn carb"...i said to him, that's ok, we all have our weaknesses on bikes..he said, but i feel like i'm not a good mechanic due to that and it takes some work away from me...told him not to worry about and asked if i could hear his bike run and he said sure...fired it right up and let it idle up (super rough i must admit) then he asked me if i knew anything about carbs and i told him a little...he said take her down the road and tell me what you think...
i said sure, i'll do that...left and went about 2 miles out and 2 miles back...
pulled it back in and shut it off and said to "runs like chit, weak on the low end, sluggish on the high side, and she's sucking some serious air somewhere"...he gave me a raised eyebrow look and said, you asked

i asked him if i could take a look and we began to tear it down to get to the carb....
there she sit, a 40mm keihin with a broken enricher tied off and loose as crap at the carb entry point...took that out blocked it off, slide the carb out of the manifold boots, open up the a/f 2 turns and i asked him, you got in jets...he said nope...told him i'd be back in 15 minutes...
went to the house and got 1 main and 1 pilot and went back down...we opened up the bottom and i took the old jets out and put in a 170 main with a 58 pilot and we put it back together...
i looked at him and said, "ok, fire her up and head down the road"...he fired her up and he looked at me and said, "SOB, it ain't sputtering and spitting no more"...i smiled and said i'll be here when you get back...he came back in about 15 minutes with bugs in his teeth (i chit you not)...dude offered to pay me or give me a set of forward controls (for an HD, but i could have made them work

)....i turned him down on both and told i might need a favor one day...he said you got it, anytime...gave him my cell number and we're gonna ride this saturday in a poker run together if it's not raining...

i love making friends, especially the mechanical way

damn good mechanic (i know him though) but as he stated, he just can't do carbs and undoubtly neither can the other mechanic in town since he was the one that had him running like crap